Neil M. Richards (Washington U Law) et al. have posted “Why AI Preemption Would Be a Mistake: Testimony of Professor Richards before the US House Judiciary Committee” on SSRN. Here is the abstract:
Congress has been considering pre-empting state laws that regulate AI for a variety of reasons. This comment argues that federal preemption of State AI laws would be a mistake for three reasons. First, AI is still in its early stages, and its potential harms and benefits are still uncertain. Preemption now of state laws touching AI would be reckless and leave consumers exposed to great harm. Second, state regulation, as opposed to federal regulation, has been the primary driver of sensible tech regulation over the past three decades of our Internet age. States have proven capable of adapting and reacting to these novel issues, and federal preemption now would prevent the states from being to respond and experiment to solve both current problem we know about, and future problems that have not yet become understood. Third, industry claims that state regulation stifles innovation are historically and empirically unsound. The states have proven effective at navigating technology regulation. They have done so in a manner that has helped foster the explosive growth of the American technology industry while also building out protections for, and thereby driving the confidence of, American consumers in these new technologies. Additionally, caution and measured action now does not preclude Congress’s taking up broad AI or technology bills in the future, when the dangers around these new technologies and the merits and costs of the various state approaches have become clearer. Broad preemption today would deprive our country of the kinds of state laws that will be essential to build the necessary trust that AI systems— like the internet before them—need to become widely adopted and fulfill their potential. Thus, preemption would be a danger to the kinds of broad adoption of useful AI technologies.
